Excerpt
Explore the role of singing teachers in an AI-dominated world, understanding the limitations of AI tools in vocal training, and the irreplaceable value of human mentorship and emotional connection in developing artistry and technique.
📹 Socials
Ready to Publish
Ready to Publish
Publish Date
Jun 8, 2025
Tags
Authors
Ready for SFC
Ready for SFC
SFC Generated
SFC Generated
Do not index
Do not index
I was at the theatre the other day with a friend, and we found ourselves talking about AI and voice education. During that conversation it became clear to me that there’s a lot of confusion and mis-information about what AI is currently capable, of, and ultimately, what it will eventually be capable of. And I made the very bold assertion that AI will never be able to replace a singing teacher… But… I think it also depends on the singer and the goals.
Hear me out. As a vocal coach who’s also an AI enthusiast, I’ve built tools that utilise AI, built apps that aid singers, and have worked with technology can analyse pitch, suggest exercises, and even simulate voices – all at the tap of a button. Tools like these can be handy practice aids, giving you immediate feedback and a fun way to track progress.
But here’s the thing: no algorithm can replace the human element of a real teacher… So the question then comes, does the signer care? Is that important to the singer? I think it depends. For hobbyists who just want to have fun, sing some songs, and be relatively pitch accurate - I think AI can do a fantastic job to help them. Will they ever grow as an artist? Probably not. Will they gain value and enjoy themselves, yes - most likely. However, if you’re anything more advanced than a hobbyist, then I don’t think AI will be a good fit - because that’s when we start diving deeper into the nuances of singing, acting, emotion, context, subtext, etc. It’s all of the “stuff” that builds artistry and performance.
This article aims to explore in more depth AI in the world of voice, and where it best sits as a companion, rather than a teacher… Let’s explore…
AI as a Vocal Assistant: Useful but Limited
It’s exciting to see what AI can do. Virtual vocal coaches can carry a library of exercises and scales, ready to lead you through a warm-up anytime. They never get tired of repeating a scale, and they’re available 24/7. Need a quick check on your pitch or rhythm? An app can give you a green light for correct notes or a score that appeals to your gaming spirit. These tools can complement your practice between lessons, helping you stay motivated and aware of technical basics like timing and intonation.
However, AI’s feedback is only skin-deep. Yes, it might catch a flat note or a timing slip. But can it sense why you missed that note? Can it see the tension in your shoulders, or notice that you held your breath in fear before that high note? Not really. One voice teacher pointed out that while apps and videos have made basic instruction widely available, they “could ever replace the experience of sitting next to a teacher” who can model good sound, observe your posture and breathing, and catch those subtle nuances in real time. An app might detect if you’re off-pitch, but it can’t adjust your stance, relax your jaw, or ease your nerves. Those finer points – the human elements of singing technique – “cannot be corrected by software”.
There’s also the issue of safety and personalisation. Singing is a very physical and personal activity. Without guidance, a singer using only an app could end up reinforcing bad habits. For example, if you tend to strain on high notes, blindly repeating exercises from an app “will not help you at all, it will actually cause harm”. A generic program doesn’t know your voice or its limits – it can’t feel the discomfort you feel. A human teacher, on the other hand, will spot the signs of strain (sometimes before you even feel it) and immediately adjust the exercise or technique to prevent injury.
So, AI tools are wonderful supplements – a way to get extra reps in and gather some objective data about your voice. I even use some of these innovations in my own studio to record lessons or analyse student progress. But they’re just that: supplements…
The Human Touch: What Real Teachers Offer (That AI Can’t)
- Empathy, Encouragement, and Personal Connection: Singing isn’t just a technical skill; it’s emotional. A great vocal coach does more than tell you when you’re on key – we tune into how you feel. We can tell when you’re frustrated, scared of a note, or bursting with confidence, and we respond in the moment. Good teachers build personal connections with students, taking the “mental pulse” of your mood and energy each lesson. Maybe you had a bad day and your voice is tight – we notice and find a way to relax you. Maybe you nail a phrase you’ve struggled with – we know exactly how big a deal that is, and we’ll celebrate with you in a way that boosts your confidence. This kind of emotional intelligence and encouragement is something no AI can truly replicate. As Dr. Jim Frankel put it, we know how to comfort, guide, cheerlead, discipline and motivate – an algorithm can’t. Singing is deeply personal, and having a mentor who cares and inspires you can make all the difference in your journey.
- Real-Time Adaptability and Feedback: Every voice is unique, and so is every lesson. If a certain explanation or exercise isn’t clicking for you, a human teacher can pivot on the spot. We improvise, use humour, tell stories, or try a dozen different analogies until the concept lands. This kind of creative adaptability – essentially teaching on your feet – is a special human skill. We read subtle cues: a confused look, a hesitant tone, or that “aha” moment in your eyes, and we adjust accordingly. An AI coach follows its programming and data; it can’t truly sense why you’re struggling with a phrase. It won’t spontaneously invent a new exercise in the moment or recall that last month a certain trick helped you overcome a similar hurdle. Human teachers tailor their approach in real time, often in ways that are more like an art than a science. We also give nuanced feedback: maybe the note was technically correct, but we sense it was emotionally flat – so we might say, “Let’s try that again, but this time think of someone you love as you sing it.” A machine that only sees pitch graphs wouldn’t know to offer that kind of insight.
- Holistic Skill Development (Technique, Artistry, and Health): A singing teacher’s job spans beyond hitting the right notes. We guide you in developing healthy technique, from breathing to posture to diction – things that require watching your body and listening to the quality of your sound, not just the frequency. For instance, I might notice a slight neck tension when you reach for a high note and suggest a relaxation exercise or a modification in vowel shape. An app likely won’t catch a “small glitch” like visible neck tension or raised shoulders. Moreover, we foster artistry: interpretation, dynamics, stage presence, connecting with the song’s story. No AI can teach you how to genuinely feel a lyric or convey emotion to an audience. Those are learned through trust, experimentation, and often the shared experience of a mentor who has performed and understands the vulnerability in singing. Mentorship is another key piece: many of us teachers have been on stage, faced auditions, battled stage fright, and so on. We share our real-life experience and stories, which not only instruct but also inspire. Students often look up to teachers as role models – a source of human inspiration that a software coach simply isn’t.
And let’s not forget accountability and motivation. When you know your teacher is going to ask how that tricky song went this week, you practice a bit more. When you’re feeling low, a teacher finds ways to reignite your passion. A piece of software doesn’t really care if you give up – but I do. Teaching (and learning) is a two-way street, a relationship. As one professor noted, teaching is a mutual obligation; a good teacher motivates and cajoles learners in ways machines can’t. We’re in this journey with you, and that human partnership can be incredibly powerful.
The Evolution of Voice Teaching
Throughout history, vocal education has experienced significant transformations. For generations, singing teachers passed down their knowledge through a lineage system – studying with master teachers, imitating techniques, and using metaphorical language to guide students ("place the voice forward," "sing from the diaphragm"). These traditional methods produced remarkable singers long before we had any technological means to observe the vocal mechanism.
Then came the scientific revolution in voice teaching. The introduction of tools like laryngoscopes and spectrographs allowed us to see what was actually happening physically during singing. This didn't replace traditional teaching methods – instead, it enhanced them. Students didn't suddenly start buying their own scopes to analyze their voices in isolation; they relied on teachers who understood how to interpret and apply these scientific insights. Many modern teachers now blend time-tested techniques with scientific insights, creating a more comprehensive approach. The science didn't make teaching less personal; it simply gave us more tools to understand and explain what great teachers had intuited all along.
Now we stand at another crossroads with AI technology. Just as the introduction of scientific tools didn't replace teachers but made them more effective, AI presents a similar opportunity. Like the spectrograms and laryngoscopes before it, AI can provide new insights and tools – but it's still just one part of the teaching toolkit. The most effective use of AI in vocal training comes when guided by teachers who understand how to interpret and apply the data it provides. I personally use them, and I enjoy them! We teachers aren't going anywhere; if anything, we're evolving and integrating new tech to serve the singer better.
So keep the apps as friends, but keep your teacher as your mentor. In this exciting new AI world, singing teachers are not only still necessary – they're the key to making all this technology actually work for you. After all, music is a human language of emotion. And it takes human insight to truly unlock its power in your voice.
TL;DR: AI tools are great practice buddies for singers – they can help with basics like pitch and provide cool feedback – but they'll never replace the personal mentorship, expert ear, and caring guidance of a real singing teacher. The future of vocal training isn't AI versus teachers; it's AI plus teachers, with human connection at the heart of it all.
Written by
